Can You Sue a Trucking Company for Negligent Hiring After a Truck Accident in Texas?

Free Case Consultation

Home » Truck Accidents » Can You Sue a Trucking Company for Negligent Hiring After a Truck Accident in Texas?

Yes, you can bring a negligent hiring claim against a trucking company in Texas. But it takes more than showing the driver had a bad record. The claim says the company acted carelessly when it hired a driver it knew or should have known was unsafe. To win, you must prove the driver’s negligence caused your crash. You must also prove the company’s hiring decision was negligent and that this failure helped cause your injuries.

Texas law adds two cautions. The Texas Supreme Court has said it has not ruled definitively on the existence, elements, or scope of a negligent hiring claim. And in its 2025 decision in Werner Enterprises v. Blake, the Court reversed a verdict worth tens of millions of dollars. The truck driver’s conduct was not a proximate cause of the crash. When the driver’s conduct fails that test, the claims against the company fail with it.

This article explains what negligent hiring means and what a Texas plaintiff must prove. It also covers how Werner affects these claims and which records show what a company knew before it put a driver on the road. If a company’s hiring choices may have played a role in your crash, our attorneys offer free consultations.

Lawyer helps man who was involved in a trucking accident caused by a negligent hire

Negligent Hiring Focuses on the Company’s Own Decisions

Most people expect a trucking company to answer for what its driver did. Negligent hiring asks a different question: what did the company do before the driver ever started a route? The claim alleges the company failed to screen the driver properly or ignored warning signs it found. It then put that driver behind the wheel of a tractor-trailer.

Warning signs can include serious at-fault crashes, license suspensions, repeated moving violations, or drug and alcohol program violations. One entry on a driving record does not make a hire negligent. Courts usually ask whether a reasonable carrier would have rejected the driver, or looked harder, after seeing the background check.

A truck accident attorney can use negligent hiring to look past the driver to the company’s own choices. Vicarious liability differs: a company answers for an employee’s on-the-job mistake no matter how carefully it hired. A hiring claim requires proof that the company itself was careless.

What You Must Prove in a Texas Negligent Hiring Claim

Negligent hiring needs two acts of negligence in Texas: one by the company and one by the driver. The Texas Supreme Court repeated that point in Werner Enterprises v. Blake, and both acts must proximately cause the injury. A plaintiff generally must prove three things:

  1. The driver was negligent, and that negligence was a proximate cause of the crash. Proximate cause has two parts, cause in fact and foreseeability. Cause in fact means the driver’s conduct was a substantial factor in bringing about your injury. A but-for link alone does not meet that standard. Electronic logging data, onboard event data, witness accounts, and the police report often matter at this step.
  2. The company was negligent in hiring the driver. You must show the company knew or should have known the driver was unfit. That can happen when it skips required checks or ignores what they show. Hiring records carry the weight at this step.
  3. The hiring failure proximately caused your injuries. In Wansey v. Hole, the Texas Supreme Court held that a negligent hiring claim requires harmful or negligent conduct by an employee hired under the company’s negligent practices. That conduct must proximately cause the injury. In practice, a jury asks whether the red flag the company missed made this kind of crash foreseeable.

An example shows why that link matters. A driver’s old DWI conviction may show a risk the company should have caught. It does little for your claim if a mechanical failure caused the crash. A record of speeding and following too closely says much more when the crash was a high-speed rear-end collision.

Expect the company to challenge every step. The Court’s May 2026 decision in In re Home Depot again says it has not ruled definitively on the existence, elements, or scope of a negligent hiring claim. The same opinion describes negligent hiring as requiring the combined negligence of two actors.

How Werner v. Blake Affects Hiring Claims Against Carriers

The crash in Werner happened on an icy stretch of I-20 near Odessa. A pickup crossed a 42-foot median and hit a Werner 18-wheeler within seconds. At trial in Harris County, the jury blamed other Werner employees for 70 percent of the fault. It assigned 14 percent to the truck driver and 16 percent to the pickup driver. The jury had considered claims about how Werner trained and supervised its driver.

The Supreme Court reversed. It assumed the truck driver’s speed was negligent and a but-for cause. Even so, speed was not a substantial factor in the crash. Without driver negligence that proximately caused the injuries, the Court said, “there can be no derivative liability” for the company. It treated negligent hiring the same way, as a claim that needs the company’s negligence and the driver’s negligence together.

The practical lesson is that strong company-side evidence cannot carry a case alone. You first need proof that the driver’s conduct substantially contributed to the crash.

Werner also left a procedural question open. Some defendants admit the driver was working for them. They then argue the jury should not hear separate evidence about hiring, training, or supervision. Courts call this the admission rule. The majority said it did not need to decide the issue. In a concurrence, Justice Young, joined by Justice Huddle, said he is inclined to adopt the rule in a future case. If Texas adopts it, the rule could keep hiring evidence from the jury when a carrier admits responsibility for its driver.

When a Negligent Hiring Claim Adds the Most

Carriers generally answer for an employee driver acting within the course and scope of employment. In those cases, a hiring claim may add less than it first appears. It tends to matter most in three situations:

  • The company disputes responsibility for the driver. A company may call its driver an owner-operator or other independent contractor and argue it owes no duty for the hire. The Texas Supreme Court has not ruled definitively on negligent hiring of an independent contractor either, so this issue needs careful legal analysis.
  • The driver’s role is unclear. The company may say the driver was off duty or off route. A hiring claim does not depend on course and scope the way vicarious liability does. The hiring failure must still have caused your crash.
  • The company’s own records show a pattern. Files that show the company ignored serious red flags may change how an insurer and a jury view its role.

A hiring claim targets the carrier that employed the driver. It does not usually reach a business that only hired the carrier to haul freight. In Home Depot, the Court held that a customer with ordinary cargo does not undertake a duty to prevent the carrier’s torts by hiring it.

Records That Show What the Company Knew Before It Hired the Driver

Federal safety rules require motor carriers to investigate each driver they employ, and those rules create a paper trail:

  • 49 CFR 391.23 requires the carrier to get motor vehicle records from each state that licensed the driver in the prior three years. It must also investigate the driver’s safety history with previous employers regulated by the Department of Transportation over that period. That history includes accident data and drug and alcohol violations.
  • 49 CFR 382.701 requires a pre-employment query of the FMCSA Drug and Alcohol Clearinghouse for commercial driver’s license holders. The query must come before the driver performs safety-sensitive work.
  • 49 CFR 391.51 requires a driver qualification file. It holds the employment application, motor vehicle records, road test documentation, and medical examiner’s certificate. The carrier keeps it for the driver’s whole employment plus three years.

Texas has adopted most of these federal rules for carriers operating within the state, with limited exceptions.

These records matter because they show what the company learned and what it did next. A missing safety history inquiry or an ignored crash record can support the claim that the company hired carelessly. A violation of a screening rule does not prove negligent hiring by itself, though. The records still must connect to the risk that caused your crash.

Hiring records also sit beside hours-of-service data, onboard event data, and maintenance records in the evidence that proves a truck accident claim. The company controls these files. Some documents, such as annual driving record checks, may leave the file three years after the carrier creates them. That is one reason our attorneys send preservation letters early in a trucking case. The letters ask the company to keep the records that show how it hired the driver.

Looking into a driver’s background can change a claim. The same hiring questions arise with other commercial vehicles. After a private ambulance driver rear-ended our client and kept driving, the insurer valued the claim from the medical records alone. It made a low offer. Our attorneys looked into the driver’s background and found a lengthy criminal history and multiple prior accidents. We also examined whether the company’s decision to hire him played a role in the crash. The case then involved more than the injuries alone, and we secured a $455,000 commercial vehicle settlement. Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

Talking With a Lawyer About a Hiring Claim

You do not need to know whether a company hired carelessly before you call. The answer often depends on company records that are difficult to obtain without legal assistance. The strongest hiring claims connect a specific red flag the company missed to the specific way the crash happened.

If a trucking company’s hiring choices may have contributed to your crash, our attorneys at Joe I. Zaid & Associates can review the driver’s background and the company’s screening records. We offer free consultations, and you owe no attorney fees unless we recover compensation.

Joe I. Zaid
Rated by Super Lawyers


loading ...
Houston Chronicle BOTB award given to Joe I. Zaid & Associates for their outstanding legal services
Top three Personal Injury Lawyers in Pasadena awarded to Joe I. Zaid & Associates
Top 10 Car Accident Lawyers in Pasadena Award
Best Car Accident Lawyers in Pearland awarded to Joe I. Zaid & Associates

Get a FREE consultation with an Experienced Attorney

Need help with your case? Get a one-on-one consultation with an experienced attorney.  Simply fill out the form below for a call back. 

Joe I. Zaid & Associates
How can we help?
Hi! Have a question about an accident or injury? We're here to help.